15 Best Replies to “What’s Cookin’, Good Lookin'”

If you’re looking for a quippy and quick-witted response to “what’s cookin’, good lookin’,” you’ve come to the right place. This article will help you answer “what’s cooking, good looking” with funny and interesting comebacks. Some of the best funny responses include:

  • What’s shakin’, bacon?
  • Don’t embarrass yourself like that again
  • That’s a secret
  • Wouldn’t you like to know
  • I’m not in the kitchen
  • I’ll have to check the oven
  • Are you looking in a mirror?
  • I didn’t put anything on
  • That’s up to you
  • Whatever you want, baby
  • I was thinking of putting a bun in the oven
  • I think I just vomited from that line
  • Don’t touch me; you might burn yourself
  • That’s not a good pick-up line, honey
  • Like I’d tell you!

The best replies to “what’s cookin’, good lookin'” are “what’s shakin’, bacon?” “don’t embarrass yourself like that again,” and “that’s a secret.” These are all great phrases that teach you how to reply to “what’s cookin’, good lookin’.” They give you some fun comebacks to match the original line.

Best Replies to What's Cookin', Good Lookin'

1. What’s Shakin’, Bacon?

“What’s shakin’, bacon?” is a similar phrase to “what’s cookin’, good lookin.” That’s what makes it so useful as a response.

You can match the original pick-up line with similar phrases to reply in the most appropriate way. You’ll get a good reaction from the person who sent the pick-up line originally.

If you want to impress the original asker, this is one of the best phrases. It shows that you appreciate their sense of humour and are willing to match it in your unique way.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • What’s shakin’, bacon? It’s nice to see that my lines haven’t completely died yet!

2. Don’t Embarrass Yourself Like That Again

“Don’t embarrass yourself like that again” is a funny response showing that you don’t appreciate the pick-up line “what’s cookin’, good lookin’.” It shows that someone has “embarrassed” themselves, but you’re willing to give them another try with a different line.

The key word is “again.” Using “again” here shows that you want the person to try a different line. Hopefully, the next one they pick is less embarrassing and is better suited to your sense of humour.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • Don’t embarrass yourself like that again. You do know that’s not a good line to use, right?

3. That’s a Secret

“That’s a secret” keeps things interesting for the asker, as it shows you’re not willing to share anything with them yet. It encourages them to explore a conversation with you to learn more about what you have to say.

This is great to show that you have a few secrets about yourself. Creating a mysterious aura like this encourages people to get more personal and see what they’re able to get out of you.

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • That’s a secret. I’m sure you’ll figure it out if you keep talking to me like that.

4. Wouldn’t You Like to Know

“Wouldn’t you like to know?” is a fun response used to test the other person for using the pick-up line. It shows you’re not willing to share much at the moment, but they might be able to crack the surface with some effort.

This phrase is great for a response to a flirty situation. It shows that you have a few things to talk about, but you will only talk about them when you’re ready to let the other party “know.”

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • Wouldn’t you like to know? I’m sorry, honey. This kitchen doesn’t open to strangers online.

5. I’m Not in the Kitchen

“I’m not in the kitchen” is a direct play into the “what’s cookin'” portion of the idiom, showing you’re not “cookin'” anything. This generally shuts down the pick-up line and shows you’re not interested in someone.

If you’re unwilling to pursue the conversation further, this phrase is your best bet. It shows that the other person has exhausted their chances of getting to know you better.

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • I’m not in the kitchen, so I couldn’t tell you!

6. I’ll Have to Check the Oven

“I’ll have to check the oven” is a funny response that plays into the “cookin'” part of the idiom. It shows that you don’t know “what’s cookin’,” but you want to joke about something being in the oven.

It’s up to you to determine what the metaphor “check the oven” implies here. It’s your flirty text message, after all. You should use it to try and continue the conversation in a positive direction.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • I’ll have to check the oven and get back to you on that. I might keep you waiting for the sake of it.

7. Are You Looking in a Mirror?

“Are you looking in a mirror?” turns the compliment around on the asker and shows that you think they are “good lookin’.” It’s great to use this as it implies that they have a “mirror” and are talking about their own reflection.

This is a good choice if you’re not willing to commit to proper flirtatious comments. It isn’t outright flirty or over-the-top. It works well when you’re just getting to know someone.

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • Are you looking in the mirror? You’re clearly the “good-looking” one around here.

8. I Didn’t Put Anything On

“I didn’t put anything on” is another good alternative referencing the “cookin'” part of the idiom. It shows that you didn’t “put anything on,” relating to not putting any food on to “cook.”

This suggests that you’re playing into the metaphor without being too obvious. It’s a great way to build a rapport with the other person and see what comebacks they might have to play around with.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • I didn’t put anything on. Why? Can you smell something? Does it smell like burning?

9. That’s up to You

“That’s up to you” is a great reply showing that you want to leave it up to the other person to decide “what’s cookin’.” This shows that you’re free and open to meeting new people and ready to explore new things together.

“That’s up to you” is a great phrase showing that you’re intrigued by the other party. It shows you want them to have some agency in coming up with what happens or what they say next.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • That’s up to you. I’m easygoing. I’ll let you decide what can be cookin’ in this kitchen.

10. Whatever You Want, Baby

“Whatever you want, baby” is a very suggestive phrase to use as a reply. You can use this seductive response to encourage someone to up their flirting game.

It shows that you’re interested in continuing the conversation, especially if you like the person. This might encourage things to get a little steamier between the two of you. If you’re not comfortable with that, you definitely shouldn’t reply with something like this.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • Whatever you want, baby. This is your time to show me what you can do. Impress me.

11. I Was Thinking of Putting a Bun in the Oven

“I was thinking of putting a bun in the oven” is a flirtatious response showing that you’re looking for a sexual encounter with someone. “Bun in the oven” is an idiom meaning you want a baby, though that isn’t always literal when used in this case.

As a reply, this shows that you’re interested in something more with the person asking you the question. You might find people respond with phrases like this on Tinder to test the authenticity or commitment of the person who asked, “what’s cooking, good looking?”

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • I was thinking of putting a bun in the oven. I don’t suppose you have some thoughts about that.

12. I Think I Just Vomited From That Line

“I think I just vomited from that line” is a funny response you can use if you don’t like the pick-up line. Pick-up lines like “what’s cookin’, good lookin'” aren’t for everyone.

If you don’t like the line, you should use this phrase. It shows that you had a physical and violently negative reaction to them using it. It often implies that the asker has ruined their chance with you as you do not have compatible senses of humour.

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • I think I just vomited from that line. What is this, the 1990s? Get a new line.

13. Don’t Touch Me; You Might Burn Yourself

“Don’t touch me; you might burn yourself” is a funny and flirty response you can use. It relates to you feeling confident and “hot” in yourself, which plays into the “good lookin'” portion of the idiom.

You might say “don’t touch me” to relate to the “cooking” portion of the idiom. It implies that you are “what’s cooking,” meaning you are the hottest thing in the room right now.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • Don’t touch me; you might burn yourself. I’m far too hot for someone like you to handle.

14. That’s Not a Good Pick-Up Line, Honey

“That’s not a good pick-up line, honey” is a direct shutdown and comeback to “what’s cookin’, good lookin’.” It shows that you don’t like the line, and it will not work well for you.

You should use this phrase when you don’t like the person texting you or don’t appreciate the idiom. “Honey” emphasises the judgmental tone you’re trying to convey.

  • What’s cookin’, good lookin’?
  • That’s not a good pick-up line, honey. You have one last chance! I’ll let you try a different one, though.

15. Like I’d Tell You!

“Like I’d tell you!” is a coy and flirty response you can use. It shows that you’re not willing to share personal information with someone, even if you only mean the phrase as a joke.

This encourages the asker to try a little harder to get to know you. They might need to talk through things more before they are able to hear what you have to “tell them.”

  • What’s cooking, good looking?
  • Like I’d tell you! I keep things like that private until the very last moment. You’ll see.

What Does “What’s Cookin’, Good Lookin'” Mean?

When someone says “what’s cookin’, good lookin’,” they’re trying to flirt with you by referencing your good looks.

“What’s cookin'” is synonymous with “what’s up” or “how are you?” You should use it when you want to ask someone how they’re doing or what’s new in their life.

“Good lookin'” is added as a rhyme with “cookin’.” It suggests that you find someone attractive, making it an excellent choice for a tinder opener.